Please wait a minute...
自然科学史研究  2019, Vol. 38 Issue (4): 405-439    
论文     
北京观象台天文仪器之被劫与归还史事拾补
周维强
台北故宫博物院图书文献处,台北 11143
Astronomical Instruments, Diplomacy and the Scientific Community: The Looting and Return of the Peking Ancient Observatory's Instruments
CHOU Wei-chiang
Department of Rare Boobs and Historical Documents, Taipei Palace Museum, Taipei 11143, China
 全文: PDF(2219 KB)  
摘要： 近代劫掠文物事件中,北京观象台天文仪器的被劫和归还是最具戏剧性的。1900年,义和团攻击北京使馆区,列强派出军队驰援。8月15日,联军攻占北京。12月2日,驻京德法部队径自协商拆走观象台天文仪器,这一掠夺行动不但在驻京联军中造成龃龉,也随即在英美等国报纸的宣传下,成为了遍传世界的国际丑闻。法国首先在国际压力下归还所掠天文仪器;德国则坚持所得,将之运往德皇波茨坦行宫无忧园作为战利品陈设。天文仪器被劫往德国后,德国国内舆论波澜甚巨,部分报章与政党曾表态应归还中国,惟在国会中决议并未通过。此后近二十年间,美国大众媒体持续追踪,加以天文学家介入,促使美国政府支持将之归还中国。一战结束后,交战各国于巴黎召开和会,签订凡尔赛和约,1921年5月6日天文仪器终得依约返归原处。百余年来,这一事件尚有许多疑点并未被厘清,本文仅就近年发现之中西史料,将天文仪器被掠与西方报导之蜂起、德美帅将之争、载沣访德与德人对抢掠之外交粉饰、一战爆发与美国天文学家的介入诸事件稍做拾补,还原天文仪器被劫与归还之重要历程。
关键词： 天文仪器;  观象台;  美国天文学会;  德国国会;  巴黎和会;  凡尔赛和约    
Abstract: Among the acts of plunder of Chinese cultural relics by foreigners in modern history, the looting of the astronomical instruments of Beijing (Peking) Ancient Observatory was perhaps the most dramatic. Looting by German and French troops stationed in Beijing began on December 2, 1900. Their actions not only embarrassed the multinational forces, but also were immediately reported by the British and American press across the world. France returned the instruments to China under international pressure, but Germany insisted on retaining them, and transported the relics to the garden at Sanssouci in Potsdam. They were later moved to the Orangerieschloss nearby. It was not until 1919, after the end of World War I, that the astronomical instruments were returned to China under the terms of the Treaty of Versailles. The looting and return of the astronomical instruments of the Beijing Ancient Observatory was a complex international political event. There are still many uncertainties surrounding the incident. This article intends to clarify some of these uncertainties using recently discovered details from historical archives and newspapers.
Key words: Astronomical Instruments    Beijing Ancient Observatory    American Astronomical Society    German Reichstag    Paris Peace Conference (1919)    Treaty of Versailles
收稿日期: 2019-06-20 出版日期: 2021-06-21
ZTFLH:  N09  
作者简介: 周维强,1967年生,祖籍浙江温岭,台湾新北人,副研究员,主要研究方向为军事技术史、社会天文学史和清代档案。
服务　　
把本文推荐给朋友
加入引用管理器
E-mail Alert
RSS
作者相关文章　　
周维强

引用本文:

周维强. 北京观象台天文仪器之被劫与归还史事拾补[J]. 自然科学史研究, 2019, 38(4): 405-439.

CHOU Wei-chiang. Astronomical Instruments, Diplomacy and the Scientific Community: The Looting and Return of the Peking Ancient Observatory's Instruments. Studies in the History of Natural Sciences, 2019, 38(4): 405-439.

链接本文:

http://www.shns.ac.cn/CN/    或    http://www.shns.ac.cn/CN/Y2019/V38/I4/405

1 蒋忠义. 北京观象台的考察[J]. 考古, 1983, (6): 526～530.
2 伊世同. 北京古观象台的考察与研究[J]. 文物, 1983, (8): 44～51.
3 Untitled[N]. The North-China Herald and Supreme Court & Consular Gazette, 1874-02-12: 131.
4 Chinese Again Attack Envoys[N]. The New York Times, 1900-08-02: 1.
5 常福元. 天文仪器志略[M]. 铅印本. 北平: 京华印书局, 1932. 4a～4b.
6 崔石竹. 北京古观象台上天文仪器被掠夺史实考[M]//崔振华. 北京天文馆文集(1957—1997). 北京: 科学技术出版社, 1997. 118～119.
7 李元. 古台蒙难百年祭[J]. 天文爱好者, 2000, (1): 2～3.
8 天琪. 古观象台遭劫纪实[J]. 世纪, 2000, (5): 8～10.
9 李元. 古观象台蒙难整百年——"科学美国人"世纪初专刊报导[N]. 科学时报, 2000-12-29.
10 陈久金, 崔石竹, 李东生. 北京古观象台[M]. 太原: 山西教育出版社, 2008. 135～137.
11 瓦德西. 瓦德西拳乱笔记[M]. 上海: 上海书店出版社, 2000. 73～74.
12 Our Own Correspondent. Peking[N]. The North China Herald and Supreme Court & Consular Gazette, 1888-04-13: 414.
13 Von Schwarzenstein A M. Ein Tagebuch in Bildern[M]. Berlin, 1902. 29～32.
14 Peking Observatory Looted[N]. The New York Times, 1900-12-03: 1.
15 Pekin Observatory Loot[N]. Boston Evening Transcript, 1900-12-03: 9.
16 The Pekin Observatory[N]. The Evening Record, 1900-12-03: 4.
17 Vandals in Peking[N]. The Meriden Daily Journal, 1900-12-03: 5.
18 Protesting Pillaging[N]. The Evening News, 1900-12-05: 12.
19 The Powers Protest[N]. Fredericksburg Daily Star, 1900-12-3: 6.
20 Powers Will Agree to American Plan[N]. Meriden Morning Record, 1900-12-03: 1.
21 恩禄. 奏报洋人占据衙署并遗失仪器书籍等情形[R]. 军机处档折件. 光绪二十七年七月十二日. 台北: 故宫博物院, 143060.
22 清德宗景皇帝实录[G]. 卷485//清实录. 第58册. 北京: 中华书局, 2008. 415.
23 恩禄. 奏报观象台房屋均已拆毁本监暂在公所照常办事[R]. 军机处档折件. 光绪二十七年七月十二日. 台北: 故宫博物院, 143062.
24 恩禄. 奏报本监各官生考试因衙署被洋人入城占据迄未办理情形[R]. 军机处档折件. 光绪二十七年七月十二日. 台北: 故宫博物院, 143063.
25 Germans and French Removed the Astronomical Instruments from the Observatory at Pekin, Preparatory to Sending them to Europe[N]. The Fostoria Review-Dispatch, 1900-12-06: 4.
26 Chaffee offends Envoys[N]. The New York Times, 1900-12-10: 1.
27 To support Gen. Chaffee: War Department Likely to Approve Protest to von Waldersee has no particulars yet[N]. The New York Times, 1900-12-11: 1.
28 Gen. Chafee's Powers in Peking Restricted[N]. The New York Times, 1900-12-12: 1.
29 Position in China[N]. The Age, 1900-12-13: 3.
30 The War in China[N]. The Tuapeka Times, 1900-12-15: 1.
31 Science Notes[J]. Scientific American, 1925, 83(24): 375.
32 Looting in China[N]. The New York Times, 1900-12-20: 8.
33 Handing Back Spoilcs[N]. The Colonist, 1901-05-07: 3.
34 奕劻. 奏为收回法国使臣交还观象台仪器由(折片)[R]. 军机处档折件. 光绪三十年七月初六日. 台北: 故宫博物院, 161808.
35 奕劻. 奏报洋兵退尽法国交还祭器情形[R]. 军机处档折件. 光绪二十七年七月二十二日. 台北: 故宫博物院, 143290.
36 法使交还仪器已赴外部致谢由[R]. 总理各国事务衙门档. 光绪三十年八月二十二日. 台北: "中央研究院"近代史研究所, 02-12-022-01-025.
37 B. F. The Peking Astronomical Instruments. (Letters to the Editor) [N]. The Times, 1901-08-22: 5.
38 Professor J. K. Rees[N]. Columbia Daily Spectator, 1907-03-11: 1.
39 Jacoby H. John Krom Rees[J]. Popular Astronomy, 1908, 16: 639～642.
40 Unique Chinese Relics[N]. The New York Tribune, 1900-12-16: 1.
41 Some Relics from Pekin: Astronomical Instruments Show European Influences[N]. Dubuque Daily Herald, 1900-12-27: 3.
42 Unique Chinese Relics[N]. Toledo Blade, 1901-01-03: 3.
43 Untitled[N]. Toledo Blade, 1901-01-03: 3.
44 The Looting of the Pekin Observatory[J]. Scientific American Supplement, 1900, 1304: 20895-20897.
45 Annual Report of the Board of Regents of the Smithsonian Institution, showing The Operations, Expenditures, and Condition of the Institution for The Year Ending June 30, 1900[R]. Washington: Government Printing Office, 1901. 185～186.
46 爱新觉罗·载沣. 醇亲王日记[M]. 北京: 群众出版社, 2014. 55.
47 Untitled[N]. The Times, 1901-08-26: 7.
48 Reichstagshandbuch 1898/1903[DB/OL]. Münchener Digitalisierungszentrum, 294. [2019-06-09]. https: //www. reichstagsprotokolle. de/Blatt4_h1_bsb00003456_00295. html.
49 The Astronomical Instruments at Peking[N]. The Straits Times, 1901-08-27: 2.
50 The Peking Observatory[N]. The Singapore Free Press and Mercantile Advertiser(Weekly), 1901-08-29: 16.
51 仪器将还[G]//《申报》影印本. 第68册. 上海: 上海书店, 1983. 723.
52 德报公言[G]//《申报》影印本. 第69册. 上海: 上海书店, 1983. 23.
53 The Peace Protocol with China was duly[N]. The Times, 1901-09-10: 7.
54 Astronomical Instruments[N]. Los Angeles Herald, 1901-09-10: 7.
55 Untitled[N]. The New York Times, 1901-09-13: 1.
56 German Took Peking Astronomic Instruments[N]. The New York Times, 1901-09-13: 1.
57 为观象台天文仪器函送物改转庆亲王函称由[R]. 总理各国事务衙门档. 光绪二十七年八月十三日. 台北: "中央研究院"近代史研究所, 01-14-012-01-019.
58 观象台天文仪器系官物庆亲王未便作主由[R]. 总理各国事务衙门档. 光绪二十七年八月十四日. 台北: "中央研究院"近代史研究所, 01-14-012-01-020.
59 仪器送与本国原年庆邸之心穆大臣即收此美意领收至发送函称不能更改由[R]. 总理各国事务衙门档. 光绪二十七年八月十五日. 台北: "中央研究院"近代史研究所, 01-14-012-01-021.
60 仪器庆邸王未敢作主奉送由[R]. 总理各国事务衙门档. 光绪二十七年八月十五日. 台北: "中央研究院"近代史研究所, 01-14-012-01-022.
61 仪器作为获胜物运到德国本拟交还惟路遥不便由[R]. 总理各国事务衙门档. 光绪二十七年八月十八日. 台北: "中央研究院"近代史研究所, 01-14-012-01-023.
62 仪器以途遥不便中国亦不索回由[R]. 总理各国事务衙门档. 光绪二十七年八月十八日. 台北: "中央研究院"近代史研究所, 01-14-012-01-024.
63 China has declined an offer by Germany[N]. The New York Times, 1901-10-03: 1.
64 Germany makes an offer, willing to return astronomical instruments to Pekin[N]. The Deseret News, 1901-10-03: 3.
65 Untitled[N]. The Times, 1901-10-03: 7.
66 The German Loot from China: Action Regarding Astronomical Instruments Severely Criticised-Germany Paid Chun's Bill[N]. The New York Times, 1901-10-14: 7.
67 The New Associated Press. Germans Object to Lionizing Prince Chun[N]. Los Angeles Times, 1901-10-04: 5.
68 Germany May Return Loot: Chinese Astronomical Instruments Cause Protest[N]. San Francisco Call, 1901-10-06: 14.
69 Untitled[N]. Thames Star, 1901-10-12: 3.
70 Untitled[N]. Thames Star, 1901-11-04: 2.
71 Germans' Conduct in China. Criticism of the Troops goes on, in spite of Praise by The Kaiser[N]. The New York Times, 1901-11-06: 9.
72 The "Conveyed" Instrument[N]. The Pittsburgh Press, 1901-10-31: 8.
73 Germany-A protest[N]. Catholic World, New Zealand Tablet, 1901-12-19: 24.
74 Deutsche Reichstag. Stenographische Berichte über die Verhandlungen des Reichstages[R]. Berlin: Norddeutschen Buchdruckerei und Verlagsanstalt, 1902.
75 Röhl J C G. Wilhelm II: Into the Abyss of War and Exile, 1900-1941[M]. Bellaigue S, Bridge Rtranslated. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2014. 202～203.
76 Distinguished Services in China[N]. The New York Times, 1902-06-24: 8.
77 仪器复旧[G]//《申报》影印本. 第77册. 上海: 上海书店, 1983. 347.
78 A Correspondent. The Fool of False Dominion[N]. The Shanghai Times, 1914-10-02: 5.
79 Teutons as Looters in Boxer Campaign[N]. The New York Times, 1917-11-14: 4.
80 Untitled[N]. The Shanghai Times, 1917-12-18: 9.
81 Campbell W W. Ambrose Swasey, 1846-1937[J]. Publications of the Astronomical Society of the Pacific, 1937, 49(290): 179.
82 参冷天, 赵辰. 原金陵大学老校园建筑考[J]. 东南文化, 2003, (3): 53～58.
83 Scaife W L. John A. Brashear: the Autobiography of A Man who Loved the Stars[M]. New York: The American Society of Mechanical Engineers, 1924. 181～194.
84 The Saturday and University Clubs: Monday's Dinner[N]. The North China Herald and Supreme Court & Consular Gazette, 1917-01-20: 127.
85 Kaiser's Peking Loot: Ruler Who Stole Valuables Now on Potsdam Lawns[N]. The Shanghai Times, 1917-05-18: 8.
86 Campbell W W. Kaiser Wilhelm as a Pillager in Boxer Days[N]. The New York Times, 1918-01-06: 71.
87 Osterbrok D E. AAS Meetings before There was an AAS: The Pre-History of the Society[C] // DeVorkin D H. The American Astronomical Society's First Century. Washington D. C. : The American Astronomical Society, 1999. 3～19.
88 DeVorkin D H. The Pickering Years[C] // DeVorkin D H. The American Astronomical Society's First Century. Washington D. C. : The American Astronomical Society, 1999. 20～36.
89 Sponberg B L, DeVorkin D H. Policies and Practice in the Early AAS[EB/OL]. [2018-09-06]. https: //had. aas. org/resources/aashistory/policies.
90 Scaife W L. John A. Brashear: the Autobiography of A Man who Loved the Stars[M]. New York: The American Society of Mechanical Engineers, 1924: 229.
91 Obituary[J]. Journal of The Royal Central Asian Society, 1929, 16(3): 408～410.
92 路透电[G]//《申报》影印本. 第155册. 上海: 上海书店, 1983. 738～739.
93 Injured China: Germany Must Restore Stolen Astronomical Instruments, Chinese Antiquity[N]. The Shanghai Times(1914-1921), 1918-12-17: 11.
94 President Woodrow Wilson's 14 Points(1918)[DB/OL]. [2018-09-11]. https: //www. ourdocuments. gov/.
95 驻丹颜公使电、驻法胡公使电、驻英施公使电(民国七年九月十六日)[G]//天津市历史博物馆. 密笈录存. 北京: 中国社会科学出版社, 1984. 26～27.
96 驻法胡公使电(民国七年九月二十五日)[G]//天津市历史博物馆. 密笈录存. 北京: 中国社会科学出版社, 1984. 28.
97 驻法胡公使电(民国七年九月二十七日)[G]//天津市历史博物馆. 密笈录存. 北京: 中国社会科学出版社, 1984. 31.
98 驻义王公使电(民国七年十月六日)[G]//天津市历史博物馆. 密笈录存. 北京: 中国社会科学出版社, 1984. 34.
99 驻英施公使电(民国七年十二月十一日)[G]//天津市历史博物馆. 密笈录存. 北京: 中国社会科学出版社, 1984. 64.
100 驻美顾公使电(民国七年十二月十一日)[G]//天津市历史博物馆. 密笈录存. 北京: 中国社会科学出版社, 1984. 64.
101 Chinese Ask Return of Boxes, War Loot[N]. Los Angeles Herald, 1919-01-01: 1.
102 Chinese and the Huns[N]. Poverty Bay Herald, 1919-01-03: 6.
103 法京陆专使电(民国八年一月十一日)[G]//天津市历史博物馆. 密笈录存. 北京: 中国社会科学出版社, 1984. 66.
104 世界路透电: 德约与中国之天文仪器[G]//《申报》 影印本. 第162册. 上海: 上海书店, 1983. 360.
105 法京陆专使电(民国八年一月二十七日、二十八日)[G]//天津市历史博物馆. 密笈录存. 北京: 中国社会科学出版社, 1984. 72～73.
106 北洋政府外交部全宗, 巴黎和会, 巴黎和会杂件, 施公使交来函稿[R]. 1919年04月. 台北: "中央研究院"近代史研究所档案馆, 03-37-022-02-001.
107 法京陆专使等电(民国八年三月十一日)[G]//天津市历史博物馆. 密笈录存. 北京: 中国社会科学出版社, 1984. 109～114.
108 各通信社电[G]//《申报》影印本. 第157册. 上海: 上海书店, 1983. 307.
109 德国将送还天文仪器[N]. 晨报, 1919-04-02∶3.
110 Return of the Loot[N]. The North-China Herald and Supreme Court & Consular Gazette, 1919-04-05: 11.
111 交还观象台仪器事[R]. 北洋政府外交部档案. 民国八年四月七日. 台北: "中央研究院"近代史研究所, 03-37-008-02-004.
112 Scientific Notes and News[J]. Science, 1919,(1268): 377.
113 Campbell W W. General Notes[J]. Publications of the Astronomical Society of the Pacific, 1919,(181): 200～202.
114 Summary of Peace Treaty given to Germany, restitution to China[N]. The Milwaukee Journal, 1919-05-08: 181.
115 China[N]. The Madison County Monitor, 1919-05-09: 3.
116 国外要闻: 欧洲媾和草约之概要[G]//《申报》影印本. 第158册. 上海: 上海书店, 1983. 134.
117 German Loot To Be Given Back To Peking[N]. The Times, 1919-03-19: 9.
118 Hills J. The Struggle for control of Global Communication: The Formative century[M]. Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 2002. 122～123.
119 Germany forced to Return Scientific Instruments Stolen from the Chinese[N]. The Portsmouth Daily Times, 1919-05-24: 3.
120 附录: 大总统布告(民国八年九月十五日)[G]//天津市历史博物馆. 密笈录存. 北京: 中国社会科学出版社, 1984. 225～226.
121 国内要闻: 美报论中国不签德约问题[G]//《申报》影印本. 第159册. 上海: 上海书店, 1983. 202.
122 Obituary[J]. Journal of the Royal Society of Arts, 1931,(4088): 465～466.
123 O'Callaghan D. To the editor of the Times: A Restitution to China[N]. The Times, 1920-01-14: 8.
124 Chen, Eugene. To the editor of the Times: A Restitution to China[N]. The Times, 1920-01-15: 8.
125 Restoration of The Astronomical Instruments[N]. The Canton Times, 1920-02-28: 8.
126 德将还我天文仪器[N]. 中外新报, 1920-03-27∶8.
127 Our Own Correspondent. Peking's Stolen Astronomical Instruments: Coming Back To China[N]. The North-China Herald and Supreme Court & Consular Gazette, 1920-03-20: 758.
128 Restore Astronomical Instruments to China[N]. The Times, 1920-07-06: 8.
129 世界路透电: 各国近事记[G]//《申报》影印本. 第165册. 上海: 上海书店, 1983. 192.
130 德归还中国天文仪器问题[N]. 晨报, 1920-07-12∶2.
131 Restore Astronomical Instruments to China[N]. The Shanghai Gazette, 1920-07-12: 6.
132 The Astronomical Instruments[N]. The Shanghai Times, 1920-07-12: 5.
133 China's Astronomical Instruments: On Their Way Home[N]. The North-China Herald And Supreme Court & Consular Gazette, 1920-07-17: 161.
134 Germany Returning Astronomical Instruments to China[N]. The Shanghai Gazette, 1920-07-15: 1.
135 Peking's Astronomical Instruments: En Route To[N]. The Shanghai Times, 1920-07-16: 2.
136 Sky Instruments Returning to China[N]. The Canton Times, 1920-07-31: 2.
137 Gen. Chang Warns That He Will Seize Peking; President Hsu Tries to Stop Army Uprising[N]. The New York Times, 1920-07-16: 14.
138 德国送还天文仪器[N]. 益世报, 1920-07-16∶3.
139 德国送还天文仪器之近说[N]. 民意日报, 1920-07-16∶3.
140 德国交还仪器问题[N]. 新华日报, 1920-07-16∶2.
141 Yate A C. The Astronomical Instruments of Peking (To The Editor of The "Spectator")[N]. The Spectator, 1920-7-17: 78.
142 The Peking Astronomical Instruments: Arrive By Nankal Maru[N]. The Canton Times, 1920-08-17: 6.
143 德已将天文仪器送还我国[N]. 晨报, 1920-08-11∶3.
144 日本将拦夺我天文仪器[N]. 晨报, 1920-08-14∶3.
145 Yate A C. To The Editor of The Spectator: The Chinese Astronomical Instruments At Potsdam[N]. The Spectator, 1920-08-21: 237.
146 交还天文仪器问题[N]. 京报, 1921-03-05∶2.
147 交还天文仪器问题[N]. 晨报, 1921-03-05∶3.
148 德国退还天文仪器已到京[N]. 益世报, 1921-04-14∶3.
149 天文仪器已到京[N]. 京报, 1921-04-14∶5.
150 京闻拾零[G]//《申报》影印本. 第169册. 上海: 上海书店, 1983. 793.
151 Schwarz R. Raub und Rückgabe astronomischer Instrumente des alten Pekinger Observatoriums durch das imperialistische Deutschland[C] //Wissenschaftliche Zeitschrift der Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin. Gesellschafts- und Sprachwissenschaftliche Reihe, 1967. 453～462.
152 Ramsay A. The Peking Who's who, 1922[M]. 北京: 通商行名编辑处, 1922. 50, 89.
153 德国归我天文仪器之经过[N]. 晨报. 1921-07-02: 3.
154 The Return of Astronomical Instruments by the German Government in 1921. A text from the Chinese daily Shen-Bao of that time[C] //Yi S, Heyndrickx J. The Verbiest Celestial Globe: A symbol of China-Europe Cooperation. Leuven: S. Vloeberghs, CEI, Cultural Centre Atrechtcollege, 1989. 17～18.
155 Loot is Returned to China[N]. Chico Record, 1921-11-15: 2.
156 Campbell W W. Return of Astronomical Instruments to China[J]. Publications of the Astronomical Society of the Pacific, 1921, 33(195): 272～273.
157 留德归国后之天文仪器[N]. 益世报, 1921-10-10∶3.
158 Rowbotham A H. The Astronomical Instruments of Peking[N]. Millard's Review of the Far East, 1921-02-26: 5.
159 尼尔·弗格森. 第一次世界大战: 1914-1918, 战争的悲怜[M]. 区立远, 译. 新北: 广场出版, 2013. 290.
[1] 陈志辉. 近代与否之辨:19世纪七八十年代欧洲人对北京古观象台的双重印象[J]. 自然科学史研究, 2020, 39(4): 476-490.
[2] 吴燕. 法国《自然》杂志上的徐家汇观象台—作为人类福祉和国家荣誉的海外科学活动[J]. 自然科学史研究, 2019, 38(2): 230-247.